For most producers in the music industry, the opportunity to work with a global icon is both thrilling and intimidating. But when songwriter and producer Ryan Tedder found himself preparing to collaborate with Paul McCartney, the pressure felt almost overwhelming. After all, Tedder wasn’t simply stepping into the studio with another pop artist—he was about to produce a track for one of the most legendary musicians in history.
Tedder, known for crafting hits for artists like Beyoncé, Adele, and Taylor Swift, had built a reputation as one of the most reliable producers in modern pop. Still, the thought of directing a former Beatle during a recording session felt surreal. When he was invited to work on McCartney’s 2018 album Egypt Station, the magnitude of the moment immediately sank in.
In later interviews, Tedder admitted that he felt deeply nervous before their first session together. In his usual work environment, he had no hesitation offering vocal direction or suggesting changes to major pop stars. With McCartney, however, that confidence briefly vanished. Telling a living legend how to approach a vocal line felt almost unthinkable.
“I couldn’t believe who I was directing,” Tedder recalled while describing the moment. Standing in the studio with someone whose songwriting had helped shape modern music history made him question how much guidance he should even attempt to give.
What happened next, however, completely shifted the atmosphere in the room.
According to Tedder, McCartney sensed the producer’s hesitation almost immediately. Rather than leaning on his decades of experience or asserting creative control, the legendary musician reportedly walked over and quietly reassured him. Leaning in, McCartney whispered four simple words that instantly broke the tension: “Tell me what to do.”
The humility of the moment stunned Tedder. Instead of acting like an untouchable icon, McCartney approached the session like a curious collaborator eager to explore new ideas. For Tedder, the gesture was both disarming and inspiring.
With that reassurance, the session transformed into a creative exchange rather than a nerve-wracking meeting with a musical legend. Tedder began offering suggestions about melody phrasing, vocal delivery, and arrangement details. McCartney listened carefully, experimenting with different approaches and embracing the process with youthful enthusiasm.
Tedder later described McCartney as a “mad genius,” not just for his songwriting instincts but for his openness to experimentation. Despite a career spanning decades and countless historic achievements, McCartney remained eager to learn from younger producers and absorb modern influences.
That collaborative spirit played a key role in shaping Egypt Station, the album they were working on together. The record blended McCartney’s classic melodic style with contemporary production techniques, creating a sound that felt both nostalgic and fresh. When the album was released in 2018, it debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard 200, proving that the former Beatle still had the ability to connect with new generations of listeners.
For Tedder, the experience became one of the most memorable moments of his career. The nervous producer who had initially feared giving direction to a music legend ended up discovering something unexpected: true greatness often comes with remarkable humility.
McCartney’s quiet request—“Tell me what to do”—was more than just a simple comment. It reflected the mindset that has kept him creatively relevant for decades: a willingness to collaborate, experiment, and keep learning no matter how legendary one’s career becomes.