Rep. Ilhan Omar ignited fierce backlash across the political spectrum after making profane, emotionally charged remarks comparing U.S. immigration enforcement to the conditions she once fled in Somalia. Speaking Friday at a Democratic field hearing in St. Paul, Omar said she never imagined witnessing such government conduct in what she referred to as the “god—- United States.”
“I don’t want to curse,” Omar prefaced, before continuing that for people who escaped failed or violent states, America was supposed to be the one place where such actions would never occur. “And we should all be ashamed that it is the United States that is allowing for this to take place,” she added, arguing that immigration enforcement actions were being broadcast globally as evidence of national moral decline.
The hearing—titled “Kidnapped and Disappeared: Trump’s Deadly Assault on Minnesota”—focused on the presence and conduct of Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents in Minnesota. Omar, whose congressional district includes much of Minneapolis, has been one of the most vocal critics of federal immigration enforcement, particularly under Donald Trump.
Tensions in the Twin Cities have been high following the deployment of roughly 3,000 federal agents after a massive fraud scandal rocked the state late last year. Critics of ICE have pointed to the killing of Renee Good by an ICE agent as evidence of what they describe as increasingly aggressive tactics, while supporters of enforcement argue the federal presence is necessary to restore order and protect public funds. Trump has publicly floated invoking extraordinary federal powers to quell unrest, though he appeared to soften that stance later in the week.
Omar’s language, however, quickly became the dominant story. Her reference to the “U.S. God—- States” drew sharp condemnation from conservatives, who argued that the remark crossed a line from policy criticism into outright denigration of the country she serves in Congress.
Among the most prominent critics was Mike Lee, who wrote on X that “no member of Congress should ever refer to our country” in such terms and openly questioned what consequences should follow. The comment thread escalated further when Elon Musk replied, “Whatever the penalty is for treason,” invoking a legal concept that carries the most severe punishments under U.S. law.
Supporters of Omar argue her remarks were an expression of anguish, not contempt, reflecting the pain of seeing America resemble the instability she once escaped. Detractors counter that words from an elected official matter—and that equating the United States with failed states undermines public trust at a moment of already heightened division.
As immigration enforcement, public safety, and national identity collide in Minnesota, Omar’s comments ensure that the debate will remain not only about policy, but about what it means to criticize America—and how far that criticism can go—while holding power within it.