Jennifer Aniston Was The Only Cast Member Of Friends Initially Locked Into Another Sitcom, Causing A Nerve-Wracking Race Against Time, But The NBC Executive Who Cast Her Took A Huge Gamble And Allowed Her To Film Both Shows Until Her First Project Was Finally Canceled, Securing Her Role As Rachel! In 1994, when NBC executives were assembling the cast for a revolutionary new sitcom called Friends, they found the perfect Rachel Green in Jennifer Aniston. There was just one, massive problem: Aniston was the only one of the six core cast members who was already contractually obligated to another network’s show, a little-known CBS sitcom called Muddling Through.
This created a nerve-wracking, high-stakes scenario where the fate of Friends—and the entire pop-culture phenomenon that followed—hung by a thread, dependent on the failure of her other show. An NBC executive took a colossal gamble, allowing Aniston to film both projects simultaneously, a move that paid off spectacularly.
The Contractual Crisis
When Friends was greenlit, Aniston was already filming her role as Madeline Cooper in Muddling Through. The situation presented a huge financial and creative risk for NBC. If the CBS show had become a success, Aniston would have been forced to leave Friends mid-season, necessitating a recast of the pivotal role of Rachel and potentially derailing the chemistry of the burgeoning ensemble. The NBC executive who championed Aniston was Don Ohlmeyer, then President of NBC West Coast. He was so convinced of Aniston’s perfect fit for the show that he authorized the unprecedented move of letting her film both sitcoms, essentially gambling on the failure of the competitor’s program.
| Show | Network | Premiere Date |
| Muddling Through | CBS | July 9, 1994 |
| Friends | NBC | September 22, 1994 |
The Fortunate Failure
NBC’s gamble relied on strategic timing. The network decided to begin airing promotional spots and early episodes of Friends against Muddling Through’s time slot, hoping to draw viewers away and hasten its demise. Fortunately for Friends—and for television history—Muddling Through failed to find an audience. The show, which focused on a mother reuniting with her family after a prison sentence, was canceled after only 10 episodes, freeing Aniston to dedicate herself full-time to the role of Rachel Green. This fortunate turn of events secured the final piece of the legendary ensemble that defined 1990s television. By the final seasons, Aniston and her co-stars were earning $1 million per episode, a testament to the value that Ohlmeyer saw in her casting nearly a decade earlier.