The search for the next generation of Marvel superheroes demands grueling auditions, but for Spider-Man and The Punisher, one of the most pivotal casting moments happened not in a sterile Hollywood studio, but in the muddy, medieval landscape of the Irish woods. Through a unique act of collaboration, two actors, Tom Holland and Jon Bernthal, helped launch each other into the stratosphere of the Marvel universe.
While filming the 2017 historical action epic, Pilgrimage, the two actors were simultaneously in the intense audition process for their respective, career-defining roles. Holland was vying for Peter Parker/Spider-Man for the MCU, and Bernthal was auditioning to become Frank Castle/The Punisher for the Netflix Marvel series.
According to Bernthal’s accounts, the remote filming location in Ireland made securing a professional setup for their audition tapes challenging. The solution was a reciprocal partnership where they relied entirely on each other.
The collaboration became legendary due to one particularly bold act. For Tom Holland’s Spider-Man audition, Bernthal helped film a pivotal action sequence that required a dramatic physical confrontation. Known for his commitment to realism, Bernthal famously performed an improvised slap on Holland to elicit a genuine, startled reaction. This act of method-acting mentorship was critical in selling the raw energy needed for the superhero role.
In return, Holland helped Bernthal film the intensely dialogue-heavy and psychologically demanding scenes required for his audition to portray The Punisher. This showcase of emotional depth was key to landing the demanding anti-hero role.
The unconventional, mutually-supported auditions paid off handsomely. Both actors secured their legendary roles around the same time: Holland debuted as Spider-Man in Captain America: Civil War (2016), and Bernthal debuted as The Punisher in the second season of Daredevil (2016).
The incident is a unique data point in Hollywood history, proving that collaboration and a fearless approach to performance—even one involving a real slap—can sometimes be the key to unlocking iconic roles. Bernthal’s boldness and Holland’s full commitment not only cemented their professional respect but also launched them both into the Marvel stratosphere.