In the early days of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), casting was everything. For the crucial role of Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow, Marvel initially looked past Scarlett Johansson, reportedly due to her association with smaller, critically acclaimed films—a background that was deemed “too indie” for a burgeoning blockbuster franchise. However, a sudden turn of events forced a re-evaluation, leading to a casting coup that defined the character for over a decade.
The First Choice and the Contractual Miss
When preparations began for Iron Man 2 (2010), the film that would introduce Black Widow to the MCU, Marvel Studios’ top choice for the super-spy role was actress Emily Blunt. Negotiations with Blunt were well underway in early 2009.
However, a conflicting obligation sealed her fate. Blunt was forced to drop out due to a pre-existing contractual commitment to the studio film Gulliver’s Travels (2010), a family comedy starring Jack Black. Blunt had signed an “optional picture deal” with 20th Century Fox for her breakout role in The Devil Wears Prada (2006), and Fox exercised that option, obligating her to star in the Jack Black film, much to her publicly stated disappointment. This sudden exit left a massive hole in the Iron Man 2 production schedule.
The Immediate Regret and the On-the-Spot Casting
Johansson, who had actively pursued the role of Black Widow and screen-tested for it before Blunt was offered the part, had been rejected. Her résumé at the time was indeed heavily weighted toward independent and critically praised films, such as Lost in Translation (2003) and The Prestige (2006).
With time running out, director Jon Favreau and Marvel Studios president Kevin Feige immediately turned back to Johansson. According to accounts from Johansson herself, the second meeting with Favreau quickly resulted in an offer. The studio’s initial hesitancy vanished as they realized the depth and gravitas Johansson could bring. In March 2009, Johansson officially signed on to the franchise with a deal that included options for multiple films.
🌟 From Indie Darling to Global Icon
The casting decision proved to be one of the most successful gambles in the MCU’s history. Iron Man 2 went on to gross over $623 million worldwide.
-
Initial Salary: For her debut as Black Widow in Iron Man 2, Scarlett Johansson reportedly earned $400,000.
-
Massive Growth: Over the next 11 years, she reprised the role in nine films. By the time she made her final live-action appearance in Black Widow (2021), her star power led to her earning an estimated $15 million for the solo film, a massive increase that highlighted her central importance to the franchise.
Related Notable Event: Johansson’s diverse background continued to serve her well. In 2020, she became one of the few actors ever to receive two Academy Award nominations in the same year—one for Best Actress in the drama Marriage Story and one for Best Supporting Actress in the indie satire Jojo Rabbit.
The initial rejection due to her “indie” pedigree only highlights the dramatic shift that secured her iconic status, proving that sometimes the best actors for blockbuster roles are found where the studio least expects them.