Before she became Wanda Maximoff/Scarlet Witch , the globally recognized cornerstone of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), Elizabeth Olsen faced a prolonged period of crushing failure and self-doubt. This painful slump nearly led her to abandon acting entirely, proving that even major stars often battle profound before finding their defining role.
The Cruel Audition Loop
Olsen first tasted critical success with the 2011 indie hit Martha Marcy May Marlene , earning widespread praise for her raw performance.She believes this breakthrough will open the doors of Hollywood. Instead, she fell into a debilitating cycle of disappointment: she constantly auditioned for major film projects, only to be rejected over and over again.
“Acting Is Not My Job”
The relentless pressure to find work, combined with the continuous failure to land roles, left Olsen facing a profound crisis of confidence . She described this period as “desperate,” reaching a point where she seriously considered giving up acting altogether. She began planning to go back to college and leave the industry, feeling that she simply couldn’t find a stable place in the competitive, rejection-heavy business.
The Decision to Revive Her Career—And Her Last Chance
Just when she felt completely burned out and ready to quit, the opportunity to audition for the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) presented itself. Joining a massive franchise was a risky decision; Olsen had worked hard to build a career in independent cinema, and a major blockbuster role could have easily overshadowed her commitment to arthouse film.
However, she decided to treat the MCU audition as her last major swing. She landed the role of Wanda Maximoff/Scarlet Witch, a decision that not only saved her career but fundamentally reshaped it.
The Unexpected Success
Her casting in the MCU provided the stability and visibility she desperately needed. She became a key figure in the studio’s blockbusters, gaining global recognition.Crucially, the franchise later allows her the creative freedom to showcase her acting depth in the critically acclaimed and highly emotional series WandaVision (2021).
Olsen’s unexpected success proved persistent that pursuit of a last-minute opportunity can lead to an unexpectedly brilliant career. Her ability to skillfully balance arthouse projects with massive franchise blockbusters has made her a rare and respected figure in contemporary Hollywood.
Would you like to know which major films Elizabeth Olsen auditioned for before landing the role of Scarlet Witch? That’s a great question, highlighting just how tough the period before her breakthrough must have been!
While the period before the MCU was marked by constant rejection and self-doubt, the search results specifically mentioned a few major roles she actively pursued and missed out on, as well as a surprise initial audition for the MCU itself:
-
Sharon Carter (MCU): Before being cast as Wanda Maximoff/Scarlet Witch, Elizabeth Olsen initially auditioned for the role of Sharon Carter (Agent 13) in Captain America: The Winter Soldier . The role eventually went to Emily VanCamp, meaning Olsen nearly joined the MCU in a completely different, and arguably less prominent, capacity.
-
Daenerys Targaryen (Game of Thrones): Olsen recalled what she described as a “horrible audition experience” for the role of Daenerys Targaryen in Game of Thrones (the part that went to Emilia Clarke).She auditioned early on, screaming the famous “out of the fire” speech in a tiny room, and admitted she didn’t even get a callback.
It is also worth noting that after she did sign her MCU contract, her commitment to the franchise led her to lose out on other roles that she deeply wanted:
-
The Lobster (2015): Olsen expressed “heartbreak” over losing a part in Yorgos Lanthimos’ critically acclaimed film, The Lobster , due to scheduling conflicts and restrictions within her Marvel contract. She stated that missing out on such roles made her feel “frustrated” because they were “more aligned with the things I enjoyed as an audience member.”
The fact that she was willing to audition for and lose roles in projects as massive as Game of Thrones and as small-but-acclaimed as The Lobster truly highlights the chaotic and surprising nature of her career just before she ultimately found stability as Scarlet Witch.